October 9th, 2026
by Cross Point Church of God
by Cross Point Church of God
Why Did Israel Ask for a King?
What 1 Samuel 8 Teaches About The Danger of Comparison
The short answer: In 1 Samuel 8, Israel's elders asked the prophet Samuel for a king so they could be "like all the nations." Samuel's sons were corrupt, so they had a real problem. But instead of asking God for His answer, they copied the nations around them. God said they had rejected Him as their king. The story warns that comparing ourselves to others pulls us away from who God made us to be.
At the bottom of Stockholm's harbor lay a warship that never fought a battle. The Vasa, built for the Swedish navy, sank in 1628 on her maiden voyage, less than a mile from where she set out. Around 30 people died.
No enemy sank her. She went down because she was built to be more than her design could carry. Guns, decks, and ornate carvings were added until she was dangerously top-heavy. A stability test before launch showed she could tip over. She sailed anyway, and she sank. The ship was raised in 1961 and is now in a museum in Stockholm.
That story is a picture of what happens when we measure ourselves against everyone around us instead of the purpose we were made for.
No enemy sank her. She went down because she was built to be more than her design could carry. Guns, decks, and ornate carvings were added until she was dangerously top-heavy. A stability test before launch showed she could tip over. She sailed anyway, and she sank. The ship was raised in 1961 and is now in a museum in Stockholm.
That story is a picture of what happens when we measure ourselves against everyone around us instead of the purpose we were made for.
Why did Israel ask for a king?
In 1 Samuel 8, the elders of Israel came to Samuel, who was getting old. His sons, who served as judges, took bribes and twisted justice (1 Samuel 8:1-3). The elders had a real problem and wanted a real solution.
But instead of bringing the need to God and waiting for His answer, they looked at the nations around them and decided they already knew the answer. They said, "make us a king to judge us like all the nations" (1 Samuel 8:5, KJV). They wanted what everyone else had. They were tired of being different.
But instead of bringing the need to God and waiting for His answer, they looked at the nations around them and decided they already knew the answer. They said, "make us a king to judge us like all the nations" (1 Samuel 8:5, KJV). They wanted what everyone else had. They were tired of being different.
Why was asking for a king wrong?
Israel already had a king. The God who parted the Red Sea and led them through the wilderness with a pillar of fire was their king. God told Samuel plainly, "they have not rejected thee, but they have rejected me, that I should not reign over them" (1 Samuel 8:7, KJV).
Their problem was not that they lacked a king. It was that their King did not look like everyone else's. You could not see His throne. He did not ride at the front of the army. Following Him took faith, and they had grown tired of that.
God let them have what they asked for, but He had Samuel warn them first. A human king would take their sons for his army, their daughters to work for him, the best of their fields, and a tenth of their grain and flocks. One day they would cry out because of the king they chose (1 Samuel 8:11-18). They heard the warning and asked anyway (1 Samuel 8:19-20).
Their problem was not that they lacked a king. It was that their King did not look like everyone else's. You could not see His throne. He did not ride at the front of the army. Following Him took faith, and they had grown tired of that.
God let them have what they asked for, but He had Samuel warn them first. A human king would take their sons for his army, their daughters to work for him, the best of their fields, and a tenth of their grain and flocks. One day they would cry out because of the king they chose (1 Samuel 8:11-18). They heard the warning and asked anyway (1 Samuel 8:19-20).
Bringing God your need vs. bringing God your plan
There is a big difference between bringing God your need and bringing God your plan. The elders did the second. They did not say, "We have a problem, show us the way." They said, "We have a problem, here is the answer, now bless it."
The pattern showed up again on the morning of the crucifixion. Pilate presented Jesus and said, "Behold your King!" The chief priests answered, "We have no king but Caesar" (John 19:14-15, KJV).
Paul warned that covetousness, wanting what others have, is a form of idolatry (Colossians 3:5). Comparison is not harmless. It leads somewhere.
The pattern showed up again on the morning of the crucifixion. Pilate presented Jesus and said, "Behold your King!" The chief priests answered, "We have no king but Caesar" (John 19:14-15, KJV).
Paul warned that covetousness, wanting what others have, is a form of idolatry (Colossians 3:5). Comparison is not harmless. It leads somewhere.
What does the Bible say about comparison?
Stories like 1 Samuel 8 were written down to teach us, so we do not repeat the same mistakes (1 Corinthians 10:11; Romans 15:4). The story is a warning flare, not a final verdict.
There is a better question than the one Israel asked. Instead of looking around and asking how to be like the people who seem to be succeeding, we can look up and ask who God made us to be. Instead of measuring our lives against someone else's highlight reel, we can ask how we are following the calling God gave us.
After His resurrection, Jesus restored Peter on the shore of the Sea of Galilee. Three times He asked Peter if he loved Him, and three times Peter said yes. Then Peter looked at John and asked, "Lord, and what shall this man do?" Jesus answered, "what is that to thee? follow thou me" (John 21:21-22, KJV).
There is a better question than the one Israel asked. Instead of looking around and asking how to be like the people who seem to be succeeding, we can look up and ask who God made us to be. Instead of measuring our lives against someone else's highlight reel, we can ask how we are following the calling God gave us.
After His resurrection, Jesus restored Peter on the shore of the Sea of Galilee. Three times He asked Peter if he loved Him, and three times Peter said yes. Then Peter looked at John and asked, "Lord, and what shall this man do?" Jesus answered, "what is that to thee? follow thou me" (John 21:21-22, KJV).
Sail the waters you were built for
God designed a version of your life before you were born. It has its own shape and its own calling. Adding what everyone else has will not improve it. Only the One who drew the plans can fulfill it.
Stop looking at the other ships in the harbor. Sail the waters you were built for.
Stop looking at the other ships in the harbor. Sail the waters you were built for.
Frequently asked questions
Where is the story of Israel asking for a king?
It is in 1 Samuel 8. God then directs Samuel to anoint Saul as Israel's first king in 1 Samuel 9-10.
Who was Israel's first king?
Saul was Israel's first king. He was anointed by Samuel after the people asked for a king like the other nations.
What does the Bible say about comparing yourself to others?
Scripture warns against coveting what others have (Exodus 20:17; Colossians 3:5) and calls each person to follow their own calling. In John 21:22, Jesus told Peter not to worry about John's path but to follow Him.
What was the Vasa?
The Vasa was a Swedish warship that sank on her maiden voyage in Stockholm in 1628 because she was too top-heavy. She was raised in 1961 and is displayed at the Vasa Museum in Stockholm.
About this post
This post is adapted from the Altars and Ashes sermon series, preached by Pastor Vondie Cook at Cross Point Church of God in Beckley, West Virginia. Join us Sundays at 9:30 or 11:00 a.m. at 110 Crescent Road, or watch online Sundays at 11:00 a.m. Also in this series: what the story of Jeroboam teaches about fear.
Cross Point Church of God
Recent
Cross Point Chronicle | November 2027
October 26th, 2026
Why Did Jeroboam Make Golden Calves? When Fear Builds False Altars
October 19th, 2026
What Does Revelation 7:9 Mean? Why Our Differences Belong at God's Table
October 12th, 2026
What Love Really Looks Like
October 12th, 2026
The Dangers of Wanting to Be Like Everyone Else
October 9th, 2026
Archive
2026
2025
April
2024
February
May
September
November
2023
April

No Comments